OHS Canada Magazine

Long-term care home with outbreak of COVID-19 variant faces lawsuit

Avatar photo

February 2, 2021
By The Canadian Press

Health & Safety COVID-19 editor pick lawsuit Variant

Barrie, Ont., facility allegedly failed to take basic precautionary measures

By Nicole Thompson

A central Ontario long-term care home devastated by an outbreak of a highly contagious variant of COVID-19 is facing a proposed class-action lawsuit from residents’ families who allege their loved ones were neglected by those charged with keeping them safe.

The unproven statement of claim filed to the Ontario Superior Court of Justice alleges Roberta Place, a long-term care home in Barrie, Ont., failed to take basic precautionary measures to protect against the novel coronavirus 10 months after the pandemic took hold in Canada.

“As a result of the defendants’ failures to adequately and properly plan, prepare and respond to the COVID-19 virus, the virus has run rampant through the Roberta Place Long Term Care Home,” the statement of claim reads.

“They failed to rectify a pattern of mismanagement, misallocation of resources and staffing, and repeated violations and cited deficiencies of infection control and prevention requirements.”

Outbreak declared Jan. 8

A COVID-19 outbreak was declared in the facility on Jan. 8, 2021, and since then more than 200 people have contracted the virus, including all but one of the residents. More than 50 residents and an essential caregiver have died.


Officials with the Simcoe Muskoka District Health Unit have confirmed that at least some of the residents have a highly transmissible variant of the virus that was originally discovered in the U.K., and the region’s top doctor says he believes everyone infected at the long-term care home has that variant, but testing is still underway.

The statement of claim alleges the facility failed to keep residents with COVID-19 separate from those who didn’t have the virus.

The document also alleges the facility failed to cohort staff.

“(Roberta Place) failed to ensure adequate staffing levels … so as to sufficiently designate each staff person to provide care for either a cohort of infected residents or a cohort of uninfected residents during the outbreak, but not both,” it reads.

The document said the facility did not enforce physical distancing or proper use of personal protective equipment.

‘Reckless, irresponsible’

“They were reckless, irresponsible, and neglectful of their responsibilities to provide high quality and compassionate care to the residents and staff of Roberta Place Long Term Care Home,” the document reads.

The statement of claim also alleges the facility failed to keep family members up to date on the state of the outbreak.

“For those class members who survive the outbreak of COVID-19 at the Roberta Place Long Term Care Home, they have endured harsh and intolerable treatment. They were locked down in their rooms, fearing for their safety and lives, knowing other residents were dying around them and unable to visit with their loved ones and family members,” the document reads.

Roberta Place did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The suit, which has yet to be certified as a class action, is seeking $50,000,000 in damages.

It’s one of a number of proposed class actions that have sprung up after COVID-19 ripped through long-term care homes across Canada.

One such suit is seeking $200 million from Extendicare, a nursing home company that either owns or operates 71 long-term care facilities in Ontario. One of its homes, Tendercare Living Centre in east-end Toronto, has seen at least 81 residents die of COVID-19 — one of the worst-hit long-term care facilities in Canada.

A second Extendicare-run facility, Orchard Villa in Pickering, Ont., has had at least 70 deaths, according to the latest provincial data.

As of Monday, the province said 3,543 of Ontario’s 6,224 COVID-19 deaths were among long-term care residents. Eleven staff members had also died.

The situation has prompted the provincial government to create the Long-Term Care COVID-19 Commission, which is examining what, exactly, went wrong in the system and how it can be prevented going forward.

The commission, which is still hearing testimony, has so far released two sets of interim recommendations.


Stories continue below

Print this page

Related Stories